Coal Car with Variable Mass

← Back to Problems
Momentum Beginner Collision

Source: High school physics (Chinese)

Problem Sets:

momentum - 1111

Problem

A coal car moves at a constant speed of $v=3$ m/s under a hopper. Coal is dropped vertically into the car at a rate of $\lambda=500$ kg/s. Ignore friction.

  1. What traction force is required to keep the car's speed constant?
  2. How much work is done by this force in one second?
  3. How much kinetic energy does the coal added in one second gain?
  4. Are the work done and the kinetic energy gained equal?

[Q1] 1500 N [Q2] 4500 J [Q3] 2250 J [Q4] No

To maintain constant velocity $v$, the traction force $F_T$ must provide the impulse to accelerate the newly added mass from zero horizontal velocity to $v$. In a time interval $\Delta t$, a mass $\Delta m = \lambda \Delta t$ is added. Its horizontal momentum changes by $\Delta p = (\Delta m)v$. The impulse required is $F_T \Delta t = \Delta p$. [Q1] The required force is $F_T = \frac{\Delta p}{\Delta t} = \frac{(\Delta m)v}{\Delta t} = (\frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t})v = \lambda v$. [Q2] The work done in time $\Delta t=1$ s is $W = F_T \cdot d = F_T (v \Delta t)$. For $\Delta t=1$ s, $W = F_T v = (\lambda v)v = \lambda v^2$. [Q3] The mass of coal added in $\Delta t=1$ s is $\Delta m = \lambda$. Its kinetic energy gain is $\Delta K = \frac{1}{2}\Delta m v^2 = \frac{1}{2}\lambda v^2$. [Q4] Comparing $W = \lambda v^2$ and $\Delta K = \frac{1}{2}\lambda v^2$, we see that $W = 2\Delta K$. They are not equal. Half the work is converted into thermal energy during the inelastic process of the coal coming to rest relative to the car.