Source: High school physics (Chinese)
Problem Sets:
Problem
A heavy ball is tied to one end of a string, and the other end is held. The ball rotates rapidly in a horizontal plane, forming a conical pendulum.
- If the ball rotates at a constant angular velocity, is a long string or a short string more likely to break?
- If the ball's linear velocity is constant, is a long string or a short string more likely to break?
[Q1] For a constant angular velocity, the tension is given by $T = m\omega^2 L$. Tension is directly proportional to the length, so a long string is more likely to break. [Q2] For a constant linear velocity, a shorter string length $L$ corresponds to a larger angle $\theta$, which in turn leads to a greater tension $T = mg/\cos\theta$. Therefore, a short string is more likely to break.
The analysis begins by considering the forces acting on the ball of mass $m$. The forces are the tension $T$ in the string and gravity $mg$. The ball moves in a horizontal circle of radius $r$ with the string of length $L$ making an angle $\theta$ with the vertical.
The radius of the circular path is $r = L\sin\theta$. Applying Newton's second law, we resolve the forces into vertical and horizontal components. The vertical components are in equilibrium:
$$T\cos\theta = mg \quad (1)$$The horizontal component of the tension provides the necessary centripetal force $F_c = ma_c$:
$$T\sin\theta = ma_c \quad (2)$$[Q1] Constant Angular Velocity ($\omega$)
For a constant angular velocity $\omega$, the centripetal acceleration is $a_c = \omega^2 r$. Substituting $r = L\sin\theta$:
$$a_c = \omega^2 L\sin\theta$$We substitute this into the horizontal force equation (2):
$$T\sin\theta = m(\omega^2 L\sin\theta)$$Since the pendulum is rotating, $\theta eq 0$, so $\sin\theta eq 0$. We can divide both sides by $\sin\theta$:
$$T = m\omega^2 L$$This result shows that for a given mass $m$ and constant angular velocity $\omega$, the tension $T$ is directly proportional to the length of the string $L$. Therefore, a longer string will experience a greater tension.
[Q2] Constant Linear Velocity ($v$)
For a constant linear velocity $v$, the centripetal acceleration is $a_c = v^2/r$. Substituting $r = L\sin\theta$:
$$a_c = \frac{v^2}{L\sin\theta}$$We substitute this into the horizontal force equation (2):
$$T\sin\theta = m\left(\frac{v^2}{L\sin\theta}\right)$$ $$T = \frac{mv^2}{L\sin^2\theta}$$This expression for tension depends on both $L$ and $\theta$. To understand how $T$ depends on $L$, we must first find the relationship between $L$ and $\theta$. We can use the vertical force equation (1), $T = \frac{mg}{\cos\theta}$, and equate the two expressions for $T$:
$$\frac{mg}{\cos\theta} = \frac{mv^2}{L\sin^2\theta}$$Solving for $L$:
$$L = \frac{v^2}{g} \frac{\cos\theta}{\sin^2\theta}$$Let's analyze this relationship between $L$ and $\theta$.
- As the angle $\theta$ approaches $0$ (nearly vertical), $\cos\theta \to 1$ and $\sin^2\theta \to 0$, causing $L \to \infty$.
- As the angle $\theta$ approaches $90^\circ$ (nearly horizontal), $\cos\theta \to 0$, causing $L \to 0$.
This shows that a shorter string length $L$ corresponds to a larger angle $\theta$.
Now, let's examine the tension using equation (1):
$$T = \frac{mg}{\cos\theta}$$Since a shorter string $L$ implies a larger angle $\theta$, the value of $\cos\theta$ will be smaller (as $\cos\theta$ is a decreasing function for $\theta \in [0, 90^\circ]$). A smaller value in the denominator results in a larger tension $T$. Therefore, a shorter string will experience a greater tension.