Shortest Time for Ferry to Cross River

← Back to Problems
Kinematics Beginner relative motion

Source: High school physics (Chinese)

Problem

Consider a ferry with a speed of 20 m/s in still water, crossing a 600 m wide river. The speed of the river current is 17.32 m/s (as found in the previous problem).

  1. In what direction should the ferry head to cross the river in the shortest time?
  2. What is the length of the ferry's path across the river for this shortest-time crossing?

[Q1] To cross the river in the shortest time, the ferry should head directly across the river, perpendicular to the current ($\theta = 0^\circ$ relative to the direct cross-stream line).

[Q2] The length of the ferry's path is given by the formula $L = d \sqrt{1 + (v_c/v_f)^2}$.

$$L = 793.7 \text{ m}$$

Let the width of the river be $d$, the speed of the ferry in still water be $v_f$, and the speed of the river current be $v_c$. We establish a coordinate system where the y-axis is directly across the river and the x-axis is downstream.

The velocity of the ferry relative to the ground, $\vec{v}_g$, is the vector sum of its velocity relative to the water, $\vec{v}_f$, and the velocity of the water (current) relative to the ground, $\vec{v}_c$.

$$\vec{v}_g = \vec{v}_f + \vec{v}_c$$

Let the ferry head at an angle $\theta$ with respect to the y-axis (the line directly across the river). The components of the velocities are:

$\vec{v}_f = (v_f \sin\theta) \hat{i} + (v_f \cos\theta) \hat{j}$ $\vec{v}_c = v_c \hat{i}$

The ferry's velocity relative to the ground is:

$\vec{v}_g = (v_f \sin\theta + v_c) \hat{i} + (v_f \cos\theta) \hat{j}$

The time $t$ to cross the river of width $d$ depends only on the y-component of the ground velocity, $v_{g,y}$:

$$t = \frac{d}{v_{g,y}} = \frac{d}{v_f \cos\theta}$$

[Q1] Direction for Shortest Time To minimize the crossing time $t$, the denominator $v_f \cos\theta$ must be maximized. Since $v_f$ is a constant speed, we must maximize $\cos\theta$. The maximum value of $\cos\theta$ is 1, which occurs when $\theta = 0^\circ$. Therefore, the ferry should head directly across the river, perpendicular to the current.

[Q2] Path Length for Shortest Time Crossing For the shortest time crossing, we set $\theta = 0^\circ$. The time taken is:

$$t_{min} = \frac{d}{v_f \cos(0^\circ)} = \frac{d}{v_f}$$

During this time, the ferry is carried downstream by the current. The distance it drifts downstream, $x_{drift}$, is determined by the x-component of its ground velocity, $v_{g,x} = v_f \sin(0^\circ) + v_c = v_c$.

$$x_{drift} = v_{g,x} \cdot t_{min} = v_c \frac{d}{v_f}$$

The total path length, $L$, is the magnitude of the total displacement vector, which has components $d$ (across) and $x_{drift}$ (downstream). Using the Pythagorean theorem:

$$L = \sqrt{d^2 + x_{drift}^2} = \sqrt{d^2 + \left(\frac{v_c d}{v_f}\right)^2}$$ $$L = d \sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{v_c}{v_f}\right)^2}$$

Substituting the given values:

$d = 600$ m, $v_f = 20$ m/s, $v_c = 17.32$ m/s. $$L = 600 \sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{17.32}{20}\right)^2} = 600 \sqrt{1 + (0.866)^2}$$ $$L = 600 \sqrt{1 + 0.749956} = 600 \sqrt{1.749956} \approx 600(1.32286)$$ $$L \approx 793.7 \text{ m}$$