Two Unequal Bulbs in Series with a Rheostat

← Back to Problems
Electric Circuits Intermediate Ohm's Law

Source: High school physics (Chinese)

Problem Sets:

ohm's law

Problem

Two light bulbs are rated <!--LATEXPH0-->'' and $110 \ \text{V}, 40 \ \text{W}$''.

  1. If the two bulbs are connected in series across a $220 \ \text{V}$ supply, will they operate properly? Explain why or why not.
  2. A rheostat is available. How should it be connected so that both bulbs operate at their rated values, and what resistance should it be set to?

(1) No -- the $40$-W bulb would burn out while the $100$-W bulb glows dimly. (2) Connect the rheostat in parallel with the $40$-W bulb; set $R \approx 201.7 \ \Omega$ (i.e. $\approx 202 \ \Omega$).

\textbf{Resistances and rated currents} (treating each bulb as ohmic at its rated point):

$$R_1 = \dfrac{U^2}{P_1} = \dfrac{110^2}{100} = 121 \ \Omega, \quad R_2 = \dfrac{U^2}{P_2} = \dfrac{110^2}{40} = 302.5 \ \Omega,$$ $$I_1 = \dfrac{P_1}{U} = \dfrac{100}{110} = \dfrac{10}{11} \ \text{A} \approx 0.909 \ \text{A}, \quad I_2 = \dfrac{P_2}{U} = \dfrac{40}{110} = \dfrac{4}{11} \ \text{A} \approx 0.364 \ \text{A}.$$

\textbf{(1) Plain series across 220 V.} A series circuit forces the same current through both bulbs, but the two bulbs have different rated currents, so they cannot both run at rated power. Numerically the series current would be $I = 220/(R_1+R_2) = 220/423.5 \approx 0.52 \ \text{A}$, which is well above the $40$-W bulb's rated $0.364 \ \text{A}$ -- it would burn out -- while the $100$-W bulb runs below its rating and glows dimly. So the answer is \emph{no}.

\textbf{(2) Using the rheostat.} For both bulbs at rated values, each needs $110 \ \text{V}$ across it, which adds to $220 \ \text{V}$, so the two bulbs go in series. The $100$-W bulb needs the larger current $I_1 = 10/11 \ \text{A}$; the $40$-W bulb only needs $I_2 = 4/11 \ \text{A}$. The extra $I_1 - I_2 = 6/11 \ \text{A}$ must bypass the $40$-W bulb -- so connect the rheostat \emph{in parallel with the $40$-W bulb}. The rheostat then carries $6/11 \ \text{A}$ at $110 \ \text{V}$:

$$R = \dfrac{110}{6/11} = \dfrac{110 \times 11}{6} = \dfrac{1210}{6} \approx 201.7 \ \Omega.$$