Source: High school physics (Chinese)
Problem Sets:
Problem
Three point charges of magnitudes $q_1, q_2, q_3$ are placed on the same straight line, in this order, and the system is in equilibrium (each charge experiences zero net force).
- Determine the signs of the three charges.
- Prove that $\sqrt{|q_1 q_2|} + \sqrt{|q_2 q_3|} - \sqrt{|q_1 q_3|} = 0$.
(1) The middle charge $q_2$ is opposite in sign to the two outer charges $q_1$ and $q_3$ (which share a sign). (2) Proven --- $\sqrt{|q_1 q_2|} + \sqrt{|q_2 q_3|} = \sqrt{|q_1 q_3|}$ follows from the equilibrium conditions on $q_1$ and $q_2$.
(1) Consider the equilibrium of $q_1$: the only forces on it come from $q_2$ and $q_3$, both lying to the right. For these forces to cancel, one must repel $q_1$ (push left) and the other must attract it (pull right). So $q_1 q_2$ and $q_1 q_3$ have opposite signs --- equivalently, $q_2$ and $q_3$ have opposite signs. By symmetry (equilibrium of $q_3$), $q_1$ and $q_2$ have opposite signs. Combining: $q_1$ and $q_3$ share one sign, $q_2$ has the opposite sign. (The middle charge is opposite in sign to the two outer charges.)
(2) Let $d_{12}$ and $d_{23}$ denote the distances between adjacent pairs, so $d_{13} = d_{12} + d_{23}$.
Equilibrium of $q_2$ (forces from $q_1$ and $q_3$ on $q_2$ have equal magnitudes):
$$\dfrac{|q_1 q_2|}{d_{12}^2} = \dfrac{|q_2 q_3|}{d_{23}^2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \dfrac{d_{12}}{d_{23}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{|q_1|}{|q_3|}}.$$Write $d_{12} = \sqrt{|q_1|}\, k$ and $d_{23} = \sqrt{|q_3|}\, k$ for some scaling constant $k$. Then
$$d_{13} = d_{12} + d_{23} = (\sqrt{|q_1|} + \sqrt{|q_3|})\, k.$$Equilibrium of $q_1$ (forces from $q_2$ and $q_3$ on $q_1$ have equal magnitudes):
$$\dfrac{|q_2|}{d_{12}^2} = \dfrac{|q_3|}{d_{13}^2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \dfrac{d_{13}}{d_{12}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{|q_3|}{|q_2|}}.$$Substituting:
$$\dfrac{(\sqrt{|q_1|} + \sqrt{|q_3|})\, k}{\sqrt{|q_1|}\, k} = \sqrt{\dfrac{|q_3|}{|q_2|}}.$$Multiplying both sides by $\sqrt{|q_1 q_2|}$:
$$\sqrt{|q_1 q_2|} + \sqrt{|q_2 q_3|} = \sqrt{|q_1 q_3|},$$which rearranges to $\sqrt{|q_1 q_2|} + \sqrt{|q_2 q_3|} - \sqrt{|q_1 q_3|} = 0$. $\blacksquare$