Relative Velocity of Wind and Runner

← Back to Problems
Kinematics Intermediate relative motion

Source: Physics Competition - Mechanics

Problem Sets:

Relative motion - point mass

Problem

A person running due west at a speed of 2.5 m/s feels the wind coming from due north. If they double their speed, they feel the wind coming from the northwest.

Find the speed and direction of the wind relative to the ground.

Wind speed is $2.5\sqrt{2}$ m/s. Wind direction is from the Northeast (blowing towards the Southwest).

Let the velocity of the wind be $\vec{v}_w = (v_{wx}, v_{wy})$ and the velocity of the person be $\vec{v}_p$, both relative to the ground. Let the +x direction be East and +y be North. The apparent wind velocity is $\vec{v}_{app} = \vec{v}_w - \vec{v}_p$.

Case 1: The person runs west at $v_{p1} = 2.5$ m/s.

$\vec{v}_{p1} = (-2.5, 0)$ m/s.

The apparent wind is from the North, so its velocity is South: $\vec{v}_{app1} = (0, -v_{app,y})$.

$\vec{v}_w = \vec{v}_{app1} + \vec{v}_{p1} = (0, -v_{app,y}) + (-2.5, 0) = (-2.5, -v_{app,y})$.

This determines the wind's West-East component: $v_{wx} = -2.5$ m/s.

Case 2: The person's speed doubles to $v_{p2} = 5.0$ m/s, still west.

$\vec{v}_{p2} = (-5.0, 0)$ m/s.

The apparent wind is from the Northwest, so its velocity is Southeast. This means its components are equal and opposite: $\vec{v}_{app2} = (k, -k)$ for some $k > 0$.

$\vec{v}_w = \vec{v}_{app2} + \vec{v}_{p2} = (k, -k) + (-5.0, 0) = (k - 5.0, -k)$.

Comparing the components of $\vec{v}_w$ from both cases:

$$v_{wx} = k - 5.0 = -2.5 \implies k = 2.5 \text{ m/s}$$ $$v_{wy} = -k = -2.5 \text{ m/s}$$

So the wind velocity is $\vec{v}_w = (-2.5, -2.5)$ m/s.

The wind speed is $v_w = \sqrt{v_{wx}^2 + v_{wy}^2} = \sqrt{(-2.5)^2 + (-2.5)^2} = 2.5\sqrt{2}$ m/s. The direction is towards the Southwest, as both components are negative and equal in magnitude.