Kinematics of a Cylinder Rolling Between Two Cylinders

← Back to Problems
Rotational Motion Advanced rigid body

Source: Physics Competition - Mechanics

Problem Sets:

Rigid body - Rolling problems

Problem

As shown in the figure, two coaxial thin-walled cylinders A and B have radii of $R$ and $2R$, respectively. A small cylinder with a radius of $R/2$ is placed between them. Cylinders A and B rotate uniformly with angular velocities $\omega_1$ and $\omega_2$ in opposite directions. There is no slipping at the contact points D (with A) and C (with B).

  1. What is the time required for the small cylinder to complete one revolution relative to the ground and relative to cylinder B?
  2. What is the magnitude of the acceleration of point C on the small cylinder relative to the ground and relative to cylinder A?
P0734-problem-1

P0734-problem-1

[Q1] $T_{S,G} = \frac{6\pi}{|2\omega_2 - \omega_1|}$, $T_{S,B} = \frac{6\pi}{\omega_1 + \omega_2}$ [Q2] $a_{C,G} = \frac{2R}{3}(\omega_1^2 + 2\omega_1\omega_2 + 4\omega_2^2)$, $a_{C,A} = \frac{8R}{3}(\omega_1+\omega_2)^2$

Let the radii be $R_A=R$, $R_B=2R$, and $r=R/2$. Let the orbital angular velocity of the small cylinder's center be $\Omega$ and its spin angular velocity be $\omega_S$. Let counter-clockwise (CCW) be the positive direction. As shown, A rotates clockwise ($\omega_A = -\omega_1$) and B rotates CCW ($\omega_B = \omega_2$). The center of the small cylinder orbits at a radius $R_{O'} = R+r = 3R/2$.

The tangential velocities at the contact points must match (no-slip condition). The velocity of a point on the small cylinder is $v = v_{O'} \pm v_{spin} = \Omega R_{O'} \pm \omega_S r$. On cylinder A (inner contact point D):

$$v_D = \Omega \frac{3R}{2} - \omega_S \frac{R}{2} = \omega_A R_A = -\omega_1 R \implies 3\Omega - \omega_S = -2\omega_1$$

On cylinder B (outer contact point C):

$$v_C = \Omega \frac{3R}{2} + \omega_S \frac{R}{2} = \omega_B R_B = 2\omega_2 R \implies 3\Omega + \omega_S = 4\omega_2$$

Solving this system of equations yields:

$$\Omega = \frac{2\omega_2 - \omega_1}{3} \quad \text{and} \quad \omega_S = \omega_1 + 2\omega_2$$

[Q1] The period of revolution is $T = 2\pi/|\omega|$. Relative to ground, the period is determined by the orbital angular velocity $\Omega$:

$$T_{S,G} = \frac{2\pi}{|\Omega|} = \frac{6\pi}{|2\omega_2 - \omega_1|}$$

The angular velocity relative to cylinder B is $\Omega_{S,B} = \Omega - \omega_B = \frac{2\omega_2 - \omega_1}{3} - \omega_2 = -\frac{\omega_1 + \omega_2}{3}$.

$$T_{S,B} = \frac{2\pi}{|\Omega_{S,B}|} = \frac{6\pi}{\omega_1 + \omega_2}$$

[Q2] The acceleration of point C is purely centripetal and directed towards the central axis. It is the sum of the acceleration of the small cylinder's center ($a_{O',G}$) and the acceleration of point C relative to its center ($a_{C,O'}$).

$$a_{C,G} = a_{O',G} + a_{C,O'} = \Omega^2 R_{O'} + \omega_S^2 r = \Omega^2 \frac{3R}{2} + \omega_S^2 \frac{R}{2}$$ $$a_{C,G} = \left(\frac{2\omega_2 - \omega_1}{3}\right)^2 \frac{3R}{2} + (\omega_1 + 2\omega_2)^2 \frac{R}{2} = \frac{2R}{3}(\omega_1^2 + 2\omega_1\omega_2 + 4\omega_2^2)$$

The acceleration of C relative to cylinder A is found using the relative acceleration formula for a rotating frame, $\vec{a}_{C,G} = \vec{a}_{C,A} + \vec{a}_{P,G} + \vec{a}_{cor}$, where P is a point in frame A coincident with C, and $\vec{a}_{cor} = 2\vec{\omega}_A \times \vec{v}_{C,A}$ is the Coriolis acceleration. All acceleration vectors are collinear.

$$a_{P,G} = \omega_A^2 (2R) = \omega_1^2 (2R)$$ $$v_{C,A} = v_{C,G} - v_{P,G} = 2\omega_2 R - (-\omega_1(2R)) = 2R(\omega_1 + \omega_2)$$ $$a_{cor} = 2\omega_A v_{C,A} = 2(-\omega_1)(2R(\omega_1+\omega_2)) = -4R\omega_1(\omega_1+\omega_2)$$ $$a_{C,A} = a_{C,G} - a_{P,G} - a_{cor} = \frac{2R}{3}(\omega_1^2 + 2\omega_1\omega_2 + 4\omega_2^2) - 2R\omega_1^2 + 4R\omega_1(\omega_1+\omega_2) = \frac{8R}{3}(\omega_1+\omega_2)^2$$