Collision of Two Spheres with Equal Kinetic Energy

← Back to Problems
Momentum Intermediate Collision

Source: High school physics (Chinese)

Problem Sets:

momentum -1112

Problem

Two small spheres, A and B, of equal radius move towards each other along the same straight line on a smooth horizontal surface. The mass of sphere A is greater than the mass of sphere B ($m_A > m_B$), and their kinetic energies are equal before the collision.

Which of the following scenarios is possible for their state of motion after the collision? (1) Sphere A's velocity is zero and sphere B's velocity is not zero. (2) Sphere B's velocity is zero and sphere A's velocity is not zero. (3) Both spheres' velocities are not zero. (4) The velocities of both spheres are reversed from their original directions, and their kinetic energies are still equal.

(3)

Let the initial velocities be $v_{A,i} > 0$ and $v_{B,i} < 0$. The initial kinetic energies are $K_{A,i} = \frac{1}{2}m_A v_{A,i}^2$ and $K_{B,i} = \frac{1}{2}m_B v_{B,i}^2$. Given $K_{A,i} = K_{B,i} = K$. The initial momenta are $p_{A,i} = m_A v_{A,i} = \sqrt{2m_A K}$ and $p_{B,i} = m_B v_{B,i} = -\sqrt{2m_B K}$. Since $m_A > m_B$, we have $|p_{A,i}| > |p_{B,i}|$. The total initial momentum of the system is $P_i = p_{A,i} + p_{B,i} > 0$. By momentum conservation, the total final momentum $P_f$ must also be positive.

(4) If both velocities reverse and their final kinetic energies are equal ($K_{A,f}=K_{B,f}$), their final momenta would satisfy $|p_{A,f}| > |p_{B,f}|$. The total final momentum would be $P_f = -|p_{A,f}| + |p_{B,f}| < 0$, which contradicts momentum conservation. So, (4) is impossible.

(2) If sphere B stops ($v_{B,f}=0$), then $P_f = m_A v_{A,f}$. Since $P_f > 0$, then $v_{A,f} > 0$. For a one-dimensional collision of impenetrable spheres, their relative order cannot change, which implies $v_{A,f} \le v_{B,f}$. The result $v_{A,f} > v_{B,f}$ violates this condition. So, (2) is impossible.

Both (1) and (3) are possible. For example, a perfectly inelastic collision results in the spheres sticking together and moving with a common velocity $V_f = P_i/(m_A+m_B) > 0$. This is an instance of (3). A perfectly elastic collision can result in sphere A stopping if the mass ratio is just right, which is an instance of (1). Since (3) represents the most general outcome of a collision, it is the most robust answer.