Comparing Recoil Velocity: Simultaneous vs Sequential

← Back to Problems
Momentum Intermediate Conservation of Momentum

Source: High school physics (Chinese)

Problem Sets:

momentum - 1111

Problem

Two people, each of mass $m$, stand on a flatcar of mass $M$ at rest. They jump off in the same horizontal direction with a velocity $v$ relative to the car.

Compare the final speed of the car for two cases: (1) they jump simultaneously, and (2) they jump sequentially.

The car acquires a greater speed when the two people jump off sequentially.

The system is the people and the car. Total momentum is conserved. Let the direction of the car's motion be negative. The velocity of a person relative to the ground $v_p$ is related to their velocity relative to the car $v$ and the car's velocity $V$ by $v_p = v+V$.

Case 1: Simultaneous jump. The initial momentum is 0. The final momentum is for the two people (mass $2m$) and the car (mass $M$). Let the car's final velocity be $V_1$.

$$0 = (2m)(v+V_1) + MV_1$$ $$V_1 = - \frac{2m}{M+2m}v$$

The final speed is $|V_1| = \frac{2m}{M+2m}v$.

Case 2: Sequential jump. Step A (1st person jumps): The system is (car + 2 people). Let the velocity of (car + 1 person) be $V_A$.

$$0 = m(v+V_A) + (M+m)V_A \implies V_A = -\frac{m}{M+2m}v$$

Step B (2nd person jumps): The initial system is (car + 1 person) with velocity $V_A$. Let the car's final velocity be $V_2$.

$$(M+m)V_A = m(v+V_2) + MV_2$$ $$(M+m)V_A = mv + (M+m)V_2 \implies V_2 = V_A - \frac{m}{M+m}v$$

Substituting $V_A$:

$$V_2 = -\frac{m}{M+2m}v - \frac{m}{M+m}v = -mv \left(\frac{1}{M+2m} + \frac{1}{M+m}\right)$$

The final speed is $|V_2| = mv \left(\frac{1}{M+2m} + \frac{1}{M+m}\right) = mv \frac{2M+3m}{(M+2m)(M+m)}$.

Comparison: We compare $|V_1| = \frac{2m(M+m)}{(M+2m)(M+m)}v$ with $|V_2| = \frac{m(2M+3m)}{(M+2m)(M+m)}v$. Comparing the numerators $2m(M+m) = 2mM+2m^2$ and $m(2M+3m)=2mM+3m^2$. Since $2mM+3m^2 > 2mM+2m^2$, we have $|V_2| > |V_1|$.